This vineyard is perched high atop a steep hillside in Green Valley along the western edge of Russian River Valley. This vineyard honors three Warrens who have been important in Merry's life: Warren Dutton, a good friend and prominent grower; Warren Arnold, a friend, partner and talented sculptor; and son Warren, who passed away in 2006. The inaugural wine shows a promising level of complexity reminiscent of Windsor Gardens, the source of the budwood.
"Sharp and tangy in crisp citrus, rhubarb and pomegranate, this lively, complex and structured wine shows secondary characteristics of forest floor, tea and dried herb. Moderately structured and ripe, it offers richness within a context of balance and grace."
Virginie Boone, Wine Enthusiast, December 2020
"A tribute to Merry Edwards’ son, who passed in 2006, as well as Warren Dutton, who established this site. Cherries plunge into savory cigar leaf, beetroot, and sage. The flavors lift and repeat, thanks to a bright acid structure, with added notes of apricot, plum and dried violets."
Meridith May, Tasting Panel magazine, Jan/Feb 2021
"Sturdier than the Bucher with its youthful tannins sticking out a bit, this wine is, accordingly, a bit closed-in at this writing, especially on the palate. Its promising aromas are possessed of tight, ripe black cherry fruit that are paralleled in style by the wine’s somewhat muscular palatal impressions. It is likely to last even longer than the Bucher entry, and it is always going to show off its structure in a more noticeable way. Give it five to eight years in bottle."
Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine, February 2021
"The color of the Merry Edwards Warren’s Hill Pinot Noir 2018, Russian River Valley, is dark purple-magenta shading to an ethereal violet rim; it’s a warm and appealing pinot noir, delivering notes of macerated red and black currants and cherries infused with cloves and sandalwood, blueberries and baked plums, with hints of wood smoke, cedar and tobacco; on the palate, the wine is characterized by soft, supple wood tones, a lithe and silky texture and deep, foresty fruit; it’s quite dry and develops some austerity on the graphite-tinged finish."
Fredric Koeppel, BiggerThanYourHead.net, April 2021
93 points / Cellar Selection
"This wine is named after two good friends of the producer with the first name Warren, Dutton and Arnold, as well as her late son. An inaugural release from a steep site in Green Valley, it explodes in a rich berry flavor and is exuberantly floral and earthy on the nose and palate. It has a stemmy intensity of baked fruit, forest and black tea that dances around firm, structured tannins."
Virginie Boone, Wine Enthusiast, November 2019
"As should be expected, the latest lot of new Pinot Noirs from this iconic producer counts more than a few successes, but this first-ever bottling from a site named for three significant “Warrens” in Merry’s life jumps out and claims a place at the very head of an accomplished class. Its intense, extraordinarily deep and keenly varietal aromas show layers and layers of ripe cherries, cola, creamy oak and subtle accents of minerals, and its equally complex, fully packed flavors are every bit as deep and compelling. While we must admit that it is so tasty and involving that we would happily accept a glass or two if offered right now, it has the balance and ineffable pedigree of an exceptionally cellar-worthy offering that will keep gaining interest well beyond its tenth anniversary."
Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine, November 2019
"Top 100 Wines of 2019: 8 to Try Before You Die"
"Storied winemaker Merry Edwards and her husband, Ken Coopersmith, sold her eponymous winery and brand in early 2019 to the Louis Roederer Champagne house. Edwards, whose winemaking career began at Mount Eden Vineyards in the Santa Cruz Mountains in 1974, progressed to Matanzas Creek Winery and Laurier Winery in Sonoma County and then on to consulting posts throughout the state. As a pioneer in introducing clonal diversity in Northern California vineyards and one of the most prominent role models for women in the wine business, Edwards bottled this Warrens’ Hill Pinot Noir to honor the late Russian River Valley grapegrower Warren Dutton; Edwards’ friend and sculptor, Warren Arnold; and her son, Warren Miller, who died in 2006 at age 18. This tribute is elegant and medium-full-bodied, with dark cherry, cranberry, and pomegranate personality. It’s a tasty tribute to important people in Merry Edwards’ life, and a sentimental swan song for the 'Queen of Pinot.' "
Linda Murphy, Sonoma Magazine, Nov.-Dec. 2019
Best of 2019 Wines
"Although 2019 saw a bounty of marvelous new wines, there were, as always, some that left an especially indelible mark on our memories."
Stephen Eliot, Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine, January 2020
"The 2017 vintage of Warrens’ Hill is the inaugural vintage. This wine really transports you, evoking images of walking through the forest after a refreshing rain. It also has playful cardamom and fresh tarragon notes that were juicy and bright on the finish."
Cathrine Todd, DameWine.com, July 2020